Red light cameras have been a point of controversy in cities across the United States for years. While municipalities argue these automated systems improve road safety and reduce traffic violations, many drivers see them as a cash grab. Recently, there's been a growing trend across various jurisdictions: judges are throwing out red light camera cases. But why is this happening, and what does it mean for drivers who’ve received a ticket?
Why Are Red Light Camera Tickets Being Dismissed?
Several legal and constitutional issues have prompted courts to toss out red light camera tickets. Some of the most common reasons include:
1. Due Process Violations
Many drivers argue that red light camera tickets violate their right to due process. Tickets are often issued to the vehicle owner, regardless of who was driving. In several cases, judges have ruled that this method fails to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
2. Improper Issuance by Private Companies
In some jurisdictions, the companies operating red light cameras are private, not governmental agencies. Judges have dismissed cases on the grounds that only law enforcement has the authority to issue traffic citations — not third-party contractors.
3. Lack of Proper Evidence
Courts have also rejected red light camera tickets where the evidence (e.g., video or still images) was blurry, inconclusive, or did not clearly establish a violation.
4. Failure to Properly Serve Notice
Some cities fail to follow the correct legal procedures when notifying drivers of a red light camera violation. If a driver doesn't receive timely or accurate notice, a judge may dismiss the case.
Cities Where Judges Are Dismissing Red Light Camera Tickets
While this varies by location, there have been noteworthy developments in cities like:
-
Chicago, IL – Judges have thrown out thousands of tickets due to improper notification procedures.
-
Los Angeles, CA – The city stopped enforcing red light camera tickets after courts frequently sided with drivers.
-
Cleveland, OH – Courts ruled the program unconstitutional unless a police officer issued the citation.
-
New Miami, OH – The village was ordered to refund millions in red light camera fines after courts deemed the system illegal.
Can You Fight a Red Light Camera Ticket?
Yes — and more people are winning than ever before. Here's how:
1. Request a Court Hearing
Don’t automatically pay the fine. Contest the ticket in court, where you can argue your case and possibly have it dismissed.
2. Challenge the Evidence
Ask for photographic or video evidence. If the quality is poor or the violation is unclear, the judge may rule in your favor.
3. Cite Precedent Cases
If you live in an area where courts have recently ruled against red light camera programs, referencing those decisions can strengthen your defense.
4. Consult a Traffic Attorney
Many lawyers specialize in traffic cases and offer free consultations. An experienced attorney can identify legal flaws in your ticket.
Are Red Light Cameras Being Phased Out?
Some cities have responded to legal pushback and public outcry by removing red light cameras altogether. Others have restructured their programs to ensure legal compliance. However, many municipalities still rely on them as a revenue source — so knowing your rights remains essential.
Final Thoughts
If you’ve received a red light camera ticket, don’t assume you have to pay it. Increasingly, judges are throwing out red light camera cases due to constitutional concerns, improper evidence, and flawed enforcement practices. Understanding the legal landscape can help you make informed decisions — and possibly beat the ticket altogether.